Is Laminate Flooring Better Than Vinyl?

Choosing between laminate flooring and vinyl can be a daunting task. Both offer impressive durability and a range of styles, while also competing on cost and ease of installation. Yet, they differ in key aspects like moisture resistance, comfort underfoot, and long-term upkeep. Understanding these differences can save you from potential headaches down the road and help you pick the most suitable option for your space.

In this article, we’ll compare laminate flooring and vinyl flooring across several dimensions, explore the downsides of laminate, examine vinyl sheet flooring, and address concerns regarding vinyl products. By the end, you’ll have a clearer picture of which flooring may be the better fit for your lifestyle and budget. How does laminate flooring compare to luxury vinyl plank (LVP)?¹

Which is better, vinyl or laminate flooring?

Whether vinyl or laminate is better depends largely on the specifics of your project: the type of room, level of humidity, amount of foot traffic, your budget, and aesthetic preferences. Here’s a breakdown of their main differences:

1. Moisture Resistance

   • Vinyl: High-quality vinyl, including luxury vinyl planks (LVP) and vinyl sheet flooring, is often completely waterproof. This makes vinyl ideal for rooms exposed to moisture—such as kitchens, bathrooms, or laundry areas.
   • Laminate: Laminate resists minor spills but can swell or warp if water seeps into its core, particularly if left unchecked. Newer water-resistant laminate lines can handle small spills, but they generally still lag behind vinyl in overall moisture protection. What is better for kitchens: laminate or vinyl flooring?²

2. Durability and Lifespan

   • Vinyl: Advanced vinyl flooring comes with a thick wear layer that stands up to scratches, dents, and everyday wear. Vinyl floors often last anywhere from 10 to 20 years, depending on quality.
   • Laminate: A sturdy laminate product can offer 10 to 15 years of service in moderate traffic conditions. However, heavier use, rough treatment, or exposure to moisture can shorten its lifespan compared to vinyl. What is the lifespan of laminate flooring vs vinyl flooring?³

3. Comfort and Warmth

   • Vinyl: Most vinyl floors have a firmer feel, although some premium lines feature attached underlayment for improved comfort and sound absorption. In cooler climates, vinyl might feel cold underfoot unless paired with additional insulation or radiant heat.
   • Laminate: Typically has a warmer and slightly softer feel than standard vinyl, due to its wood-based core. Many homeowners find laminate’s underfoot feel cozier, especially if installed with underlayment.

4. Design and Aesthetics

   • Vinyl: Modern technology allows vinyl to mimic wood, stone, or tile patterns realistically. Luxury vinyl planks feature embossed textures that provide a convincing look and feel.
   • Laminate: Regarded for its authentic wood-like appearance. Laminate planks have a photographic layer that’s extremely detailed, and the material can mimic different wood species, grains, and finishes. Some high-end laminates appear nearly identical to real hardwood.

5. Installation and Cost

   • Vinyl: Installers can choose glue-down or click-lock versions. High-end vinyl flooring can approach laminate’s cost, though sheet vinyl remains one of the cheapest flooring solutions.
   • Laminate: Usually installed as a floating floor with an easy click-lock mechanism. Pricing ranges from budget-friendly to premium, depending on thickness, brand, and wear layer quality.

Verdict:
Vinyl flooring may be the better choice in areas prone to spills, humidity, or heavy wear. Laminate offers a warm feel and can provide a realistic wood appearance. Budget, environmental conditions, and your personal preference for underfoot comfort are key factors in determining which is truly better for your home.

What is the downside to laminate flooring?

Despite the appeal of laminate’s affordability, aesthetics, and ease of installation, it has some drawbacks that may influence your decision:

1. Moisture Vulnerability
   Laminate’s wood-based core can swell or warp if moisture seeps between planks or under them. Though newer water-resistant laminates reduce this risk, they may not match the full waterproof capability of vinyl. Kitchen spills or bathroom humidity can jeopardize laminate’s integrity over time if not dealt with promptly.

2. Limited Lifespan and Refinishing
   Unlike hardwood, laminate can’t be sanded and refinished. Once the wear layer deteriorates or the surface is significantly scratched, the plank may need replacing. This limits laminate’s potential lifespan, especially under intense wear. What are the disadvantages of laminate flooring?⁴

3. Less Realistic Under Close Inspection
   Laminate has greatly improved in imitating wood’s grain and texture, but some discerning eyes can spot the difference up close. The photographic layer and repeated patterns can appear less authentic.

4. Environmental Impact
   Traditional laminate flooring often uses melamine resin and adhesives that emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs). While many manufacturers now provide low-VOC or eco-friendlier products, it’s important to check certification labels. Additionally, laminate is not as straightforward to recycle or dispose of compared to natural wood or cork.

Which is better, vinyl sheet flooring or laminate?

Vinyl sheet flooring and laminate cater to different needs and priorities. Both can be budget-friendly, yet they diverge significantly in terms of water resistance, comfort, and appearance:

1. Moisture Protection

   • Vinyl Sheet Flooring: Often comes in large rolls, with minimal seams. When properly installed, sheet vinyl is highly water-resistant. If you’re aiming to avoid water damage in places like bathrooms or mudrooms, sheet vinyl is a safe bet.
   • Laminate: Can handle minor spills, but water infiltration is a concern. What is the difference between vinyl sheet flooring and laminate?⁵

2. Comfort and Installation

   • Vinyl Sheet: Installation can be more challenging for DIYers since cutting and fitting large sheets around corners or fixtures can be cumbersome.
   • Laminate: Known for user-friendly click-lock planks. It tends to feel sturdier and warmer underfoot than sheet vinyl.

Verdict:
Vinyl sheet flooring may surpass laminate in waterproof performance, but laminate generally provides a more realistic wood aesthetic and easier plank replacement.

Why avoid vinyl flooring?

Vinyl flooring, including sheet vinyl and luxury vinyl planks (LVP), has grown in popularity, but certain factors cause some homeowners to shy away from it:

1. Environmental Concerns
   Vinyl typically contains polyvinyl chloride (PVC) and can release volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Although many vinyl products now meet low-VOC standards, the environmental impact during production and disposal remains a concern. Is laminate or vinyl more environmentally friendly?⁶

2. Repair Challenges
   Repairing or patching damaged vinyl sheet sections isn’t straightforward. You might need an entire roll replacement or a noticeable patch job.

Conclusion

Is laminate flooring better than vinyl? The answer depends on your unique circumstances:

• Laminate may win over those craving a warm, authentic wood aesthetic for living areas or bedrooms.
• Vinyl excels in water resistance, making it ideal for kitchens, bathrooms, and basements.

Balancing the downsides of both materials will help you make an informed decision for your space.

Footnotes: