Which Is Best for Flooring: Engineered Wood or SPC?

When choosing between engineered wood and SPC (Stone Plastic Composite) flooring, it’s important to understand the differences in both materials' durability, aesthetic appeal, and maintenance requirements. Whether you're renovating your home or looking for a reliable flooring solution for your business, knowing which one is the best fit for your needs can make a significant difference.

Engineered wood and SPC flooring each have their unique benefits and drawbacks. Engineered wood brings warmth and elegance to your space, while SPC flooring offers durability and moisture resistance. Let’s explore which one is better suited to your lifestyle and requirements.

Is engineered timber flooring better than SPC?

Engineered timber flooring and SPC flooring each have their pros and cons, and which one is better depends on your priorities.

Engineered timber flooring offers a natural look and feel, ideal for those seeking warmth and authenticity. It is made of real wood, which gives it a distinct appearance and a luxurious feel. However, engineered timber is more vulnerable to moisture damage compared to SPC¹, which is water-resistant. SPC flooring, on the other hand, is more durable and less likely to expand or contract with temperature changes.

Dive Deeper: Comparing the Benefits of Engineered Timber and SPC Flooring

Engineered wood is often preferred for its natural wood appearance, which is favored in more traditional or high-end interior designs. SPC, however, provides superior moisture resistance, making it an excellent option for bathrooms, kitchens, and basements, where moisture levels can fluctuate. SPC’s easy installation and lower maintenance costs are key selling points for many homeowners.

Is SPC better than wood?

SPC flooring and traditional hardwood flooring (like oak, maple, or cherry) offer different advantages. SPC is engineered for durability and ease of maintenance, while wood floors provide timeless beauty.

SPC flooring is better if you prioritize durability, moisture resistance, and cost-effectiveness. Wood flooring is more suited for those who want the luxury of natural materials and don’t mind performing extra care, such as refinishing, every few years.

Dive Deeper: SPC Flooring vs. Traditional Hardwood

When it comes to durability, SPC flooring holds an advantage in high-moisture areas like kitchens and bathrooms, where wood flooring can warp or swell over time. However, if you prefer the beauty of natural wood and the ability to refinish it, hardwood is the way to go. Consider how long you plan to stay in your home and whether you want the option of refinishing your floors in the future.

Is SPC flooring engineered hardwood?

SPC flooring is not engineered hardwood, but it shares similarities with it. SPC flooring is made from a combination of limestone, polyvinyl chloride (PVC), and stabilizers, creating a durable, waterproof, and low-maintenance surface. Engineered hardwood is made from real wood veneer layered over plywood or MDF.

SPC flooring is not engineered hardwood, but it mimics the appearance of hardwood flooring at a more affordable price. SPC’s construction makes it resistant to water damage, unlike engineered hardwood, which can swell and warp when exposed to moisture.

Dive Deeper: Why SPC is Not Engineered Hardwood

While SPC can look like wood due to its design options, it doesn’t provide the same tactile feel or warmth that genuine hardwood offers. Engineered hardwood is often a better choice for those who want the authentic feel of wood underfoot, whereas SPC is ideal for a more budget-friendly and durable option that still looks great.

What is the most scratch-resistant engineered wood flooring?

Some engineered hardwood options are more scratch-resistant than others. In general, woods like oak, maple, and hickory tend to be more resistant to scratches due to their dense grain.

The most scratch-resistant engineered wood flooring includes harder woods like hickory and oak, which are naturally denser and more durable. However, it's also important to consider the wear layer thickness and finish of the engineered wood to ensure maximum protection from scratches.

Dive Deeper: Choosing the Best Scratch-Resistant Engineered Wood

If you want the most durable engineered hardwood, opt for a thick wear layer (around 4mm or more) and a high-quality finish like aluminum oxide, which increases scratch resistance. Even with these features, engineered wood will still be more susceptible to scratching compared to SPC, which is designed to withstand heavy foot traffic and impact better.

What is the weakness of SPC flooring?

While SPC flooring has many advantages, it does have some weaknesses. One of the biggest drawbacks is its inability to be refinished, unlike hardwood floors. Over time, it may also show wear and tear from heavy impacts or scratches.

The biggest weakness of SPC flooring is that it can’t be refinished like wood floors. If the surface gets scratched or damaged, the flooring may need to be replaced, whereas hardwood floors can be sanded down and refinished to restore their original appearance.

Dive Deeper: Long-Term Durability of SPC Flooring

While SPC is durable, it doesn’t have the same long-term value as hardwood, especially if you plan on staying in your home for many years. You may need to replace your SPC flooring if it becomes excessively damaged, whereas engineered hardwood can be refinished to extend its lifespan. However, SPC's resistance to moisture and stains is a significant advantage for areas that see high humidity.

What are the disadvantages of engineered timber flooring?

Engineered timber flooring offers many benefits, but it’s not without its drawbacks. One major disadvantage is its susceptibility to moisture damage, which can cause the boards to swell or warp if exposed to water over time.

The main disadvantages of engineered timber flooring are its sensitivity to moisture and the possibility of fading or discoloration over time. Engineered wood is also generally more expensive than SPC, and the need for refinishing every few years can be a downside for some.

Dive Deeper: Moisture Sensitivity and Maintenance of Engineered Timber

While engineered timber floors can be more moisture-resistant than solid hardwood, they still need to be maintained with care in high-moisture areas like bathrooms or basements. The finish on engineered wood can fade over time, especially in areas with heavy sun exposure. SPC flooring, in contrast, remains unaffected by these environmental factors, making it an easier option for long-term durability.

How long will SPC flooring last?

SPC flooring is a highly durable and long-lasting option. With proper maintenance, SPC floors can last anywhere from 20 to 30 years, making them a great long-term investment.

SPC flooring typically lasts between 20 to 30 years, depending on the quality of the material and how well it's maintained. The wear layer thickness and installation method will also play a role in how long the floor lasts.

Dive Deeper: Ensuring Longevity of SPC Flooring

To maximize the lifespan of your SPC flooring, it’s essential to follow manufacturer care guidelines, such as cleaning with non-abrasive cleaners and using furniture pads to prevent scratches. Additionally, choosing high-quality SPC products with a thicker wear layer will extend its durability.

Does SPC flooring scratch easily?

SPC flooring is highly scratch-resistant, but it can still scratch if exposed to sharp objects or heavy furniture. It’s generally more scratch-resistant than engineered wood and other types of flooring, but it’s not completely immune.

SPC flooring doesn’t scratch easily, but it can still get damaged with heavy impacts or abrasive objects. Using mats and furniture pads can help prevent scratches from forming.

Dive Deeper: Preventing Scratches on SPC Flooring

To protect your SPC flooring from scratches, keep debris off the surface by regularly sweeping or vacuuming. Additionally, use furniture pads or area rugs in high-traffic areas to reduce the likelihood of scratches. Avoid dragging heavy furniture across the floor, as this can cause damage.

What thickness of SPC flooring is best?

When selecting SPC flooring, the thickness of the wear layer is one of the most important factors to consider. For residential use, a wear layer of 12 mil (0.3mm) to 20 mil (0.5mm) is recommended.

The best thickness for SPC flooring depends on the intended use of the space. For high-traffic areas, opt for a thicker wear layer, such as 20 mil or more. Thicker floors are more durable and resistant to scratches, while thinner options may suffice for less demanding areas.

Dive Deeper: Choosing the Right SPC Thickness

The thickness of SPC flooring affects both its durability and comfort. A thicker SPC floor with a high-quality wear layer is a better investment in the long run, especially in high-traffic or commercial spaces. For residential applications, 12-20 mil is ideal, while thicker layers can be used for commercial spaces where durability is crucial.

Conclusion

Both engineered wood and SPC flooring have their advantages, depending on your priorities. If you're looking for a luxurious, natural wood feel and are willing to maintain it, engineered wood may be the better option. However, if you need a more affordable, moisture-resistant, and scratch-resistant solution, SPC flooring is a strong contender. Ultimately, the best choice comes down to your specific needs, budget, and preferences.

Footnotes: